I have watched with great interest the brawl in Malaysia concerning the word "Allah." It is most widely understood as the name of the god to which Muhammed directed his prayers and worship, but linguistically it is used by others to actually mean the the one true God. I make the case here that they are not one in the same, which is backed by Saint Augustine, who taught that if your deity asks you to do wretched things, it is not God. The Church presently is following the semantic line that, since there is only one God, whatever misguided paths that others follow will lead to him, so Allah = God. Fair enough. I do believe there's room for academic disagreement on this, since we all want the same thing.
Sadly, the use of "Allah" by Christians has resulted in a rash of fire-bombings, many churches have had to suspend Masses because of threats, and those who have held Masses have suffered many casualties. (I would posit that this supports my contention: if Allah demands killing those who call on his name in this way, then he cannot be the trinitarian God.)
The next chapter, though, becomes more bizarre.
Kuala Lumpur: Non-Muslims in Malaysia's Selangor state have been asked
to refrain from using 35 Islamic terms and references, including the
word "Allah", either orally or in writing to propagate their religion.
If a formal complaint is lodged, the violator could be charged in a
court under Selangor Shariah Criminal Offences Enactment 1995 and can
be fined upto RM3,000 (about 35,000 rupees) or face two years' in jail
or both.
The list of terms not to be used by non-Muslims include Allah,
Firman Allah (Allah's decree), solat (daily prayers), Rasul (prophet),
mubaligh (missionary), mufti, iman (faith), Kaabah (the Holy cubicle),
Qiblat (direction in which the Muslims pray), and Haji (Muslims who
have done his pilgrimage), Selangor Islamic Religious Department (Jais)
director Mohammed Khusrin Munawi said.
"These are listed under the Control and Restriction of the
Propagation of Non-Islamic Religious Enactment. They cannot be used to
promote religions other than Islam," he noted.
The words for daily prayer, missionary, prophet and faith. Faith? The academic disagreements have their limits, and simple common sense must stand up to this. While I try to limit this blog to matters concerning stricly Things Feminine, we all use language. I could raise the spectre of what this same faith does to women, but there is no need. If we cannot use words, we cannot discuss anything. As I said, bizarre.
Recent Comments